Affiliate Disclosure vs — Full Guide for Comparing vs — Full Guide for Comparing and are two eminent online cupids, which specialize in connecting singles of the same religion and beliefs. It is a brilliant idea to create couples based on a shared religious background. Both iconic matchmakers perfectly cope with this task. Still, how to decide which one suits singles most if they both are so popular among the Catholic community? The expert comparison will help us detect the winner.

It will be correct to start with the background of these two brands. and can boast of a long-term existence in the dating niche, though CatholicMatch is a bit older. The portal will soon mark a two-decade anniversary. Both online cupids focus purely on connecting soulmates that follow Catholicism. They have a strict approach to the registration procedure, asking newbies to pass personality tests. It results in excellent profile quality – profiles are super informative, making the lovebird search more efficient.

The first impression about a dating portal plays an integral role because Catholic males and females appreciate convenient navigation. Both have well-crafted websites; the same refers to their mobile versions. Daters may check the romantic success stories of former members. It is vivid proof that both platforms indeed help men and ladies build lasting relationships for life. CatholicMatch has a community forum where members may interact in a loyal environment and seek help if they have some questions about using the portal.

The first impression matters, and both services have no issues with interface and usability. This round ends in a tie.

How to Choose a Better One?

It seems like the vs competition won’t be easy-going. Both platforms go equal by now. If singles hesitate about making a correct choice, some recommendations may be helpful.

People need to ask themselves a couple of questions to pick up a site that suits them most:

  • What is my goal? – Catholic males and females have a mature attitude to relationships. They don’t hunt for one-night hookups and sex affairs. They opt for finding spouses among like-minded and intelligent individuals with shared beliefs.
  • Can I connect with singles nearby? – Location plays an integral role in partner search. Daters may chat via DMs for months, but they should have an opportunity to meet each other for actual dates too. Thus, it is better to check whether an online cupid connects individuals from the same vicinity.
  • What is the pricing? – Typically, all matchmakers provide free services, such as account creation or flirting via Likes. However, only paid subscription opens broad prospects for interaction (DMs, live chats, etc.). If you realize that a premium package is too expensive for you, better opt for a more affordable alternative.

The final recommendation is to rely on your individual preferences and demands when picking up a top-notch matchmaking site. vs What About Price Comparison?

The price comparison will help detect a favorite in this or battle. Both brands allow newbies to join for free and even pass a personality quiz. Chatting is traditionally the privilege of VIP daters only. Still, CatholicMatch allows free users to express their interest in someone particular via Likes and Winks. In contrast, CatholicSingles members have to pay for this option. In other words, males and females have zero interaction tools if they don’t spend a coin to upgrade their membership plans. and both allow daters to search for sweethearts using a filtering system. However, advanced filters are also a perk for VIPs only. The same refers to a more intimate interaction in chatrooms. Free subscribers can’t reply to messages; they can see when someone views their profiles. However, CatholicMatch allows free daters to send emoticons (similar to emojis) to express their interest. It is better than nothing because free subscribers at CatholicSingles can’t even send Smiles. Moreover, CatholicMatch will refund you money spent for six months if you cannot find your match during this period.

Pricing table
1 month – $29 1 month – $27
6 months – $89 3 months – $50
Annual – $120 6 months – $76

The premium package cost per month is almost equal at and, but the former doesn’t even allow free subscribers to send Likes and Smiles. So, the winner in this category is CatholicMatch! vs Who Can Join?

People who follow Catholicism have a rigorous approach to dating. They don’t hunt for one-night hookups but focus on finding spouses for life. That is why community quality matters a lot to them when deciding on which website to join. So, what kind of people are there? The audience comparison will help choose between vs

CatholicSingles’ Community Quality

Let’s start with CatholicSingles. As the name clarifies, the online cupid aims to connect singles of the same religion only, i.e., Catholicism. Males slightly dominate over female members in the ratio 53% to 47%. Though it doesn’t position itself as the site for straight individuals only, they still make the community’s dominant share. The average age of subscribers varies from 30 to 50. As one may see, the primary audience consists of mature daters. There is a low risk of bumping into youngsters searching for casual sex affairs. Newbies pass ID verification, which reduces the chance of getting into fake profiles or bots.

CatholicMatch’s Community Quality

What’s about the second opponent of this vs battle? It also connects soulmates of the Catholic faith only. The service can boast a balanced ratio of men and women. The audience is mostly straight. The number of gay members makes less than 3%. Male and female users aged 25-40 make the majority on the site, but many seniors 50+ are also present. subscribers pass a precise compatibility test at the registration stage. Thus, the profiles are very informative; people may attach up to 50 photos. The number of complaints about the scammers’ presence or fake accounts is almost zero thanks to strict moderation policy.

It seems like this round ends in a draw. Both services have high-quality userbases, consisting of intelligent and mature Catholic men and ladies. Features

The competition between and is getting tougher. Both brands have multiple benefits in comparison with niche alternatives. Thus, it will be a good idea to analyze each cupid’s original features separately. Let’s start with a sign-up stage. CatholicSingles doesn’t bother newcomers with a lengthy registration procedure. Still, newbies have to answer a series of questions. Apart from typical questions about appearance and hobby, daters need to answer a block of queries related to faith (like what role it plays in their lives). Also, there is a question about bad habits (whether a person smokes or not). Singles also should describe their potential sweethearts (their character traits, relationship goals, etc.).

Such a detailed questionnaire results in high profile quality and makes a lovebird search process more fruitful. Advanced filters help people connect with like-minded individuals. There is also an option to search by vicinity to match hotties living in the same area. The biggest miss of CatholicSingles is that free daters have zero interaction tools. They can’t even share Smiles or Likes. Respectively, DMs and chatrooms are also the privilege of VIPs only. Thus, if a person doesn’t plan to browse profiles without an opportunity to text someone, a premium package is a must-have. The only bad thing is that the site doesn’t have a money guarantee option if you fail to find someone special during a specified timeframe.

When comparing or, the first platform has fewer features than its more experienced opponent. The CatholicSingles members may arrange group dates in a church. These are not standard hookup dates but more like group meetings of several people of the same faith. Another unusual feature is Prayer Intention, when males and females ask other singles to pray for them. The idea is that praying unites people and allows them to feel a special bond. CatholicSingles subscribers also participate in public discussions on the Dateworthy forum, where they share their movie preferences and discuss whether a film is suitable for a date. Features

Now it’s time to analyze the second participant of this intense and battle. CatholicMatch is one of the pioneer portals, aiming to connect males and females of the same beliefs. Registration takes some time due to a detailed questionnaire that newbies have to fill. It has several blocks related to appearance description, hobbies/interests, and a series of religious questions (like what faith means to me). It also has a passage dedicated to a potential lovebird: singles need to describe what traits they want to see in their partners. Newcomers may also join via Facebook and upload up to 50 photos.

All newbies pass obligatory ID verification. Moderators use this tool to protect singles from fraud. CatholicMatch members may ask other daters 20 questions, which they figure out themselves. This brilliant idea allows people to see whether a person meets their preferences at the very beginning of their communication. If answers match your demands, the two of you may pass to direct messaging. Free users may express their interest in other daters via Likes. It is a strong advantage of the brand over its opponent. If members seek a closer interaction, they should consider purchasing a paid package. Premium customers may get in touch via DMs and chatrooms. Free daters receive messages too, but they can read them only after ten days. A filtering system works brilliantly at CatholicMatch. Even basic filters are effective, while advanced tools allow users to select potential partners by appearance, location, family status, etc.

Analyzing vs, the former has more ace features. In contrast to its opponent, CatholicMatch allows members to pass a temperament test. It aims to help singles understand whether they can potentially have mutual chemistry if they become a couple. Catholics may arrange group chats in the Community Forum. It is an excellent opportunity to meet like-minded individuals and interact in a friendly environment. Singles may also set private meetings and even turn on cams during their video dates.

Emoticons are another perk at CatholicMatch. It may be helpful for shy singles who are afraid of breaking the ice via messages. Instead, they can send a cute emoji to express their warm feelings. Finally, the site has a guarantee feature. If a person can’t find a lovebird on the portal within six months after joining, CatholicMatch will compensate for the whole package cost. Newcomers may look through multiple romantic stories of former members. It is another proven sign that the online cupid knows how to connect single hearts.

And the Winner Is: or

So, what is the champion of this battle – or Let’s summarize the overall impression of these two services. Both have a strict approach to couple-building: newcomers have to fill detailed questionnaires to join the portals. However, CatholicMatch also allows newbies to link via Facebook. The sites have convenient navigation and very active members of the same faith and beliefs. Strict moderators check all newcomers not to let scammers get to the platforms.

Unlike its opponent, CatholicSingles have zero interaction tools for free subscribers (they can’t even share Smiles or Likes). In contrast, CatholicMatch allows free members to express interest via emoticons and read messages. It also can boast of many unique features, making one’s search more joyful and stress-free. CatholicMatch also has a moneyback guarantee. Numerous success stories speak in favor of the portal’s efficiency in connecting soulmates of the same religion.

It seems like we have a winner of this vs competition, and it’s CatholicMatch!

MS, RD & Writer
Sarah has an empathetic mindset, and she never judges other people, no matter what they are going through. She is capable of understanding her clients’ issues, and empathy enables her to find the causes and advice on the way forward.
Submit your review

Top Dating Websites

Read review
Read review
Read review